Continuity of tradition: Megalithic pots with arrow-work graffiti
found at Sembiankandiyur village in Nagapattinam district.
CHENNAI:
In recent excavations in Nagapattinam district in Tamil Nadu,
megalithic pottery with graffiti symbols that have a strong resemblance
to a sign in the Indus script have been found. Indus script expert
Iravatham Mahadevan says that what is striking about the arrow-mark
graffiti on the megalithic pottery found at Sembiyankandiyur and
Melaperumpallam villages is that they are always incised twice
and together, just as they are in the Indus script.
The
Hindu published on April 27 a report ("Megalithic period
pottery found") on megalithic pottery and urns found at Sembiyankandiyur,
along with [in most of the editions] a photograph of three pots
with arrow-like graffiti symbols on each pot.
In
all the three pots, the arrow-like symbol appeared two times each
and next to each other.
The
Tamil Nadu Archaeology Department found these pots during excavations
at Sembiyankandiyur between February and April 2008 after a school
teacher, V. Shanmuganathan, unearthed a polished neolithic axe
from the garden of his house at Sembiyankandiyur in 2006. The
axe had engravings that resembled the Indus script.
In
May 2007, the Department found several pots at Melaperumpallam
near Poompuhar during a trial excavation. Some of these had the
same arrow-like symbol occurring twice on them, and always adjacent
to each other.
According
to Mr. Mahadevan, seals unearthed at Mohenjodaro (now in Pakistan)
in the 1920s have similar arrow-like signs that also occur twice
and always together. There are several seals with the Indus script
and engravings of a bull or a unicorn where the arrow-like sign
always occurs in pairs.
While
the megalithic/Iron Age pottery in Tamil Nadu is datable between
the third century B.C. and third century A.D., the Indus script
belongs to the period 2600 B.C. to 1900 B.C. of the mature Harappan
period.
"In
spite of the enormous gap in time and space between the Indus
civilisation sites and [the] Tamil Nadu [sites], it appears that
the megalithic graffiti of Tamil Nadu have continued the tradition
of the Indus script," Mr. Mahadevan said.
"Despite
a slight difference in the graphic of the arrow-like symbol found
on the megalithic pottery of Tamil Nadu and the sign in the Indus
script, the fact is that they always occur in double and together.
So this requires further study and investigation."
In
1960, B.B. Lal, former Director General of the Archaeological
Survey of India (ASI), wrote a paper in the publication Ancient
India brought out by the ASI, with a photographic catalogue of
the megalithic and chalcolithic pottery with graffiti marks and
comparing them with the signs of the Indus script. "Since
then, many more examples of pottery with graffiti marks that have
a strong resemblance to the Indus signs have been found at Sanur
near Tindivanam in Tamil Nadu and Musiri (Pattanam) in Kerala,"
Mr. Mahadevan said.
Particularly
significant was a large megalithic terracotta plate found at Sulur
near Coimbatore, with symbols closely resembling an inscription
on a tablet found at Harappa, which is also in Pakistan now. Hence,
"there is distinct possibility that the megalithic symbols
and the corresponding signs of the Indus script have the same
significance and meaning," he said. (The terracotta plate
from Sulur is on display at the British Museum in London).
In
his paper, "A megalithic pottery inscription and a Harappa
tablet: a case of extraordinary resemblance," published in
the Journal of Tamil Studies, Volume No.71, June 2007, Mr. Mahadevan
said: "I suggest that close resemblances are possible only
if the south Indian megalithic script is related to the Indus
script. Further, the common sequence found on the Sulur dish and
the Harappa tablet may indicate that the languages of the two
inscriptions are related to each other."